Freedom Charity / Law in practice / England and Wales
FGM Cases & Law
The legal cases. The lessons for protection.
Understand prosecutions under FGM law, the landmark convictions in England and Wales and how FGM Protection Orders can be used to prevent harm. Each case has a dated outcome and supporting source.
Freedom Explains — safeguarding commentary from Freedom Charity, founded by Aneeta Prem. Court judgments and outcomes are identified separately from the charity’s analysis. Updated 26 October 2026.
Selected landmark prosecutions
Criminal cases and appeals
This section covers three landmark FGM convictions and a separate criminal sentence appeal. These proceedings must not be confused with Family Court protection orders. They are selected examples, not a complete record of investigations, allegations, referrals or survivors.
2019 · England · First FGM conviction
The first conviction
A mother was convicted after a girl suffered injuries requiring emergency treatment. Expert evidence contradicted an accidental-injury explanation. The mother received an 11-year sentence. The child’s identity is protected.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
The significance of a conviction is not simply the sentence: it demonstrates that children can receive legal protection even where the abuse has been hidden. Professionals must listen carefully, seek appropriate specialist support and preserve evidence without attempting their own investigation.
2023 conviction / February 2024 sentence · England
Amina Noor: FGM overseas
Amina Noor was convicted on 26 October 2023 of assisting a non-UK person to carry out FGM on a British girl in Kenya. Mr Justice Bryan sentenced her to seven years’ imprisonment on 16 February 2024. The Court of Appeal upheld the sentence in July 2024. The victim has lifetime anonymity.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
The years between the abuse and the child’s disclosure matter. A trusted teacher may hear something that was concealed for a long time. Schools need clear procedures for private disclosure, recording, referrals and ongoing support. A delayed disclosure can still be significant evidence.
Kaky was convicted in September 2024 of conspiracy to commit FGM and forced marriage following a plan involving travel to Iraq. The planned harm was prevented. His initial four-and-a-half-year sentence was increased to seven years by the Court of Appeal on 24 January 2025. The CPS described this as the first conviction for conspiracy to commit FGM in England and Wales. Official sentencing update (February 2025).
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
Safeguarding action can succeed before a child is harmed. Plans for overseas travel, communications and evidence of coercive intent can matter, and FGM and forced marriage risks should be considered together when they overlap.
2024 · Court of Appeal Criminal Division · Sentencing law
R v Noor
Judges: William Davis LJ, Cockerill J and Linden J · Court of Appeal · 4 July 2024
[2024] EWCA Crim 714. Following Amina Noor’s October 2023 conviction under section 3 of the Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003 and her seven-year sentence in February 2024, the Court of Appeal dismissed her sentence appeal on 4 July 2024. The seven-year sentence remained in place. The court explained how sentencing judges should approach serious FGM offences where there is no offence-specific guideline. Lesson: judges may look carefully at sentencing principles for analogous offences, while distinguishing the specific elements of an FGM offence. Criminal sentence appeals are distinct from Family Court protection cases.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
Sentencing an unusual offence requires careful reasoning, not simplistic comparison with another crime. The Court of Appeal’s dismissal of the challenge explains why the offence, the proven harm and the statutory framework matter.
The Emad Kaky prosecution involved both FGM and forced marriage, so it is also included on the Forced Marriage Cases & Law page. Cross-listing one mixed-offence case is deliberate, not duplication of the article.
Family Court / Published judgments
FGM protection: what courts decided
FGM-related Family Court judgments explain how judges assess medical evidence, actual risk, travel, children’s wishes and the proportionality of restrictions. These are not criminal convictions. In some cases, the court found the evidence did not justify the allegation or a continued order.
2015 · Family Court · Allegation not established
Re B and G (Children) (No 2)
Judge: Sir James Munby, President of the Family Division · 14 January 2015
[2015] EWFC 3. The court examined conflicting medical evidence about suspected FGM. It found that the local authority had not proved that the girl had undergone FGM or was at future risk. The judgment also discussed FGM as potential significant harm in family law. Lesson: medical findings must be tested carefully; an allegation must never be presented as an established offence.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
FGM is serious harm, but a serious allegation still needs reliable evidence. Medical opinions must be tested carefully and no family’s risk should be inferred from ethnicity or community background alone.
2018 · Court of Appeal · FGMPO travel ban set aside
Re X (A Child: FGMPO)
Judges: Irwin LJ, Moylan LJ and Asplin LJ · 31 July 2018
[2018] EWCA Civ 1825. The Court of Appeal allowed the father’s challenge to an absolute travel ban, set that part of the protection order aside and ordered a fresh hearing. It did not dismiss the underlying need to consider FGM risk. Lesson: protective orders must be necessary, proportionate and supported by findings specific to the child.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
An absolute prohibition can be protective but is not automatically proportionate. The court must weigh the evidence about this child, the risks of travel and the effect of restrictions on family life.
[2019] EWHC 1990 (Fam). After a Court of Appeal-ordered rehearing, Mr Justice Cobb retained protective measures but permitted one carefully controlled visit to Egypt, with the maternal grandfather, supervised arrangements and safeguards over the child’s passport. The order prohibited FGM and required the parents to prevent it. Lesson: protection can be tailored to an evidenced risk; the law does not require an automatic, indefinite travel ban.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
The court’s tailored travel arrangements illustrate that safeguards can be specific, monitored and proportionate. A travel permission is not a finding that FGM risk never existed; it reflects the circumstances and conditions before the court.
2024 · High Court · Prohibited Steps Order discharged
AS v Waltham Forest
Judge: Ms Justice Harris DBE · 5 November 2024
[2024] EWHC 2808 (Fam). A longstanding travel restriction originally intended to address FGM concerns was discharged. The court weighed updated expert risk evidence, the teenager’s developing autonomy and the interference with family life. Lesson: restrictions must be reviewed and proportionate. This was a Prohibited Steps Order, not an FGM criminal conviction.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
Protection orders should not continue by inertia. As circumstances and a young person’s wishes evolve, courts and professionals may need updated evidence and a fresh assessment of whether restrictions remain justified.
Judge: HHJ Vincent, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge · Fact-finding judgment 10 March 2025; welfare judgment 2 September 2025
[2025] EWFC 282 and 283. The court did not find an alleged risk of FGM established. It concluded that applications to restrict a mother’s and her daughters’ travel were part of a pattern of coercive control by the father. Lesson: courts must assess the evidence and consider whether protection-order proceedings themselves are being misused.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
Courts must remain alert to the misuse of safeguarding language as a means of coercion. Allegations require evidence, and the protective process itself should not become a way to control someone’s movements or relationships.
2026 · High Court · FGM Protection Orders discharged
MO v FO
Judge: Mr Justin Warshaw KC, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge · 27 July 2026
[2026] EWHC 2442 (Fam). Following examination of competing allegations about a two-year-old child, the court was not satisfied that the alleged FGM plan had occurred or that a protective order was justified. Existing orders were discharged. Lesson: even for serious safeguarding concerns, orders require an individual, evidenced risk assessment.
Freedom Explains — why this case matters
Discharging an order after examination of the evidence does not trivialise FGM. It illustrates the need for a proper evidential basis, individual risk assessment and continuing scrutiny of restrictions.
How to read these judgments: A rejected allegation does not mean FGM is harmless, and an order being discharged does not mean the original concern was necessarily improper. What matters is the court’s specific findings, the evidence at the relevant date and the legal test.
The judgments are anonymised. Do not infer or disclose children’s identities, family locations or further details beyond what publication orders permit.
Criminal law and professional duties
How FGM law works
Offences
The Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003 makes FGM a criminal offence in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, including certain related and overseas offences. Scotland has separate legislation. The offence and jurisdiction must be identified for each case.
Overseas offences
The law can cover specified conduct and assistance abroad when legal jurisdictional tests are met. The Noor and Kaky cases show why travel plans, communications and evidence from overseas can be crucial.
Sentencing
Relevant offences under sections 1, 2 and 3 of the 2003 Act may carry a maximum sentence of 14 years’ imprisonment on indictment. Penalties vary by offence and procedure.
Safeguarding
Prevention does not depend on a conviction. Professionals must follow relevant safeguarding duties, including the FGM mandatory-reporting duty where it applies. Do not investigate or confront alleged perpetrators independently.
Latest published Ministry of Justice statistics · April to June 2026
FGM Protection Orders: the figures
During April–June 2026, the Family Court recorded 20 applications for FGM Protection Orders (FGMPOs) and 53 orders in England and Wales. Since central recording began in 2018, the totals to the end of June 2026 were 709 applications and 1,601 orders.
An FGM Protection Order (FGMPO) can be used to protect a girl or woman at risk of FGM or someone who has already experienced it. Conditions may include travel or contact restrictions and surrender of passports. Orders can be made urgently. Breach can be prosecuted as a criminal offence carrying a maximum sentence of five years’ imprisonment or handled by the Family Court as contempt of court.
A protection order is not a criminal conviction. An application or order records a protective court process, not proof that FGM occurred. Court statistics cannot be read as a count of victims. The latest published quarterly figures should always be labelled with their date and measure.
Frequently asked legal questions
FGM: key answers
Is FGM illegal in the UK?
Yes. England, Wales and Northern Ireland are covered by the Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003, as amended, and Scotland has separate FGM legislation. The precise offence and jurisdiction depend on the case. Read the CPS legal guidance.
Can someone be prosecuted for arranging FGM overseas?
Potentially. UK laws contain provisions covering specified overseas conduct. The case of Amina Noor involved assisting FGM overseas, while Emad Kaky was convicted of conspiracy to commit FGM. See the Kaky sentencing update.
What is an FGM Protection Order?
An order made by the Family Court to protect someone at risk of FGM or someone who has experienced it. Terms can include restrictions on travel and surrender of documents. It is not itself a criminal conviction. Read the official guidance.
Can an FGM allegation be rejected by a court?
Yes. Judges must make findings based on the evidence, not assumptions. Re B and G [2015] EWFC 3 shows why specialist medical evidence matters; FJ v MH and MO v FO also address unproved risk allegations. This does not diminish the seriousness of FGM. Read Re B and G.
Case summaries describe selected reported convictions and official guidance. This resource primarily explains England and Wales law. Survivors’ identities and statutory reporting restrictions must be respected.